They said I opened a trade 2 minutes before the news, which was not possible, I had only two trades that day,
To everyone and anyone reading here is my evidence pulled between my emails and commit capital dashboard.
On April 1st I had two positions opened here are the times below.
2026-04-01 12:33:38
2026-04-01 13:23:58
penalty date according to the email :
04/01/2026 13:58:24
Reason they gave
Violation Name: News trading
Position: Position: 13554228Title: ISM Manufacturing PMISymbol: USDImpact: HIGH
These were 16:00 PM news on the 1s of April 2026
So I checked on Forex factory and the trades were roughly 2 hours before the news mentioned.
So I Opened a ticket to ask what rule did i miss. this was the response they gave me before they closed the ticket, no evidence no details.
"Upon investigation your trade was placed at 15:58 which is 2 minutes before the news was released hence your account has been breached "
I went back to check my dashboard if there is any trade that matches this, and there was none.
The dashboard shows on 1st of april 2026 two trades were closed at the following times
I checked the Analysis hub trading journal to see if I can get anymore information
I saw the 1st of April and checked durations for my trades:
First trade was open for: 1 hour, 24 minutes, 44 seconds
GBPNZD. 2026-04-01 12:33:38 2026-04-01 13:58:22
Second trade was open for:
34 minutes, 18 seconds
USDCHF.c 2026-04-01 13:23:58 2026-04-01 13:58:16
Non are within two minutes of the PMI unless there was another PMI on the same day that was high impact and Forex factory missed.
or number two, there is some hidden rule that we break that is not covered in their terms and conditions, privacy policy and FAQ
I am open to being corrected, but based on the data available to me, there is no evidence of a trade being opened 2 minutes before news.
This raises concerns about transparency and how violations are determined.
Claim your business profile now and gain access to all features and respond to customer reviews.
Transforming Trading with Comit Capital.
We elevate trading through state-of-the-art technology, strategic mindset coaching, and exceptional customer service, setting new standards in the industry.
