mysterytacklebox.com

4.4
4.4 Based on 1.4K reviews

...

Unclaimed Profile
Business profile not claimed
This business hasn’t yet claimed their profile on our platform and may be unaware it's listed. As a result, their rating might not fully reflect their customer service or responsiveness.

Average Rating

4.4

/
5

1.4K Reviews

5 Star
77%
4 Star
9%
3 Star
3%
2 Star
3%
1 Star
8%

All Reviews

Filter Reviews

Review Time

guska97
Not worth it. Similar boxes received.

Not worth it. I received two "Pro" boxes that are nearly identical and feel like overstock someone is trying to offload. There are a few decent items, but more than half are just average. It's better to visit a local fishing store or a well-known retailer to pick what you need. The savings aren't significant, and it takes nearly two weeks for delivery. I wanted to give it a shot, but I ended up with no real benefit!

2
Date of experience: Dec 10, 2025
Kami Ahlin
Lied to get my info, don’t trust you

I was going to buy my son this for his 21st bday and have a box mailed once a month for a year. However, I was promised a $10 off code if I gave them my email and phone but it wasn’t until after I did that that it said you couldn’t use it on a regular box. That’s really shifty business practice. I didn’t want to sign up for the whole year until I saw that it was worth the money so I was starting with buying just a month. Now I’m not buying anything all thanks to a false promise and code that doesn’t work. Upon reading reviews, I see I am not the first and not the only one with this same problem but yet you continue to do this shady business practice. That’s not okay and I won’t be back unless I’m shown yoh can suddenly be trusted.

1
Date of experience: Oct 19, 2025
Amanda Neu
Highly Recommend MTB

I’ve used MTB for a few years now. The subscription boxes make great gifts and are helpful if you’re just starting your fishing journey. 10/10 recommend!

5
Date of experience: May 02, 2025
Mia Wallace
Best Monthly Surprise!

I’ve been using mystery tackle box for years now and it’s hand down the best fishing subscription on the market. The variety and quality of lures + detailed fishing tips make it something I look forward to every month. I’m constantly losing lures but my tackle box is always set up thanks to MTB!

5
Date of experience: May 01, 2025
Kelsey
I’m catching a ton more fish

I’m catching a ton more fish

5
Date of experience: Apr 30, 2025
Devon Stierle
I got my friend a 3 month membership…

I got my friend a 3 month membership for a Christmas present and you guys kept sending him boxes after that. I went on and canceled it to stop the charges over a month ago and I just got a notification that you are sending another box to him. I want my money back and for you to stop sending packages.

1
Date of experience: Apr 29, 2025
Mitch
Love getting something new

Love getting something new, the same ole wonderbread spinner day in and day out gets old. Nice to switch things up.

5
Date of experience: Apr 27, 2025
Elephant Man
I bought 2 of the regular boxes at…

I bought 2 of the regular boxes at dicks sporting goods and they had the exact same things and they both weren’t that good

2
Date of experience: Apr 24, 2025
Hagan Nichols
1 out of 2 wasn’t what I pay for

I bought two of the inshore saltwater fishing pro boxes at a store where I live at in Texas, and in one of the two boxes was a bass fishing mystery box, and the other one was the inshore saltwater fishing box pro. I had good experience with your products before, but now I am not happy for it.

1
Date of experience: Apr 21, 2025
cynthia L. Gibbons
Wish to give 4 stars

Send a gift to my grandson and my issue has been rectified wonderful experiences before in years past with mystery tacklebox I can include this one as well!!Life is so much better when you raise kids up to respect nature to fish responsibly hunt responsibly kids need to experience the outdoors, not sit with their faces stuck in social media and playing video games so go out and enjoy nature🌺

1
Date of experience: Apr 18, 2025

We use cookies to personalize your experience. By continuing to visit this website you agree to our use of cookies

More