whenwefirst.com

4.8
4.8 Based on 15 reviews

When We First is a modern dating platform that was developed by a matchmaker to help customers date better both online and offline. Matchmaking is at the heart of what we do, and we believe that technology and the human element combined can revolutioniz...

Unclaimed Profile
Business profile not claimed
This business hasn’t yet claimed their profile on our platform and may be unaware it's listed. As a result, their rating might not fully reflect their customer service or responsiveness.

Average Rating

4.8

/
5

15 Reviews

5 Star
93%
4 Star
0%
3 Star
0%
2 Star
7%
1 Star
0%

All Reviews

Filter Reviews

Review Time

Stephanie Almeida
First date with When We First and it was perfection

First date with When We First and it was absolute perfection. We had so much in common we were laughing and talking the whole time. He was such an amazing person and we already have our second date planned. I don’t think I’ve ever been on a date with someone who has so much in common with me.

5
Date of experience: Oct 26, 2025
Dan Friedman
Available for any questions

Available for any questions, engaged in susbtatnial outreach for clients, hosts an interesting and engaging variety of social events for members and new guests, overall exciting and a good way to get guidance in navigating a murky dating scene

5
Date of experience: Oct 02, 2025
John Boyer
Excellent!

When We First is premium and 2nd to none. Highly Recommended!

5
Date of experience: Sep 19, 2025
Danielle De La Fuente
Not for everyone

I signed up in February, really excited to explore matchmaking! However, I quickly learned not all they pitched is true. The company is very new and seems to have limited men available to match you with. From 4 dates I went on, only 1 was a potential match. I have found the matchmaking experience soul sucking and unpleasant. I wish whoever wishes to try this luck, but I would have preferred simply going on a vacation to meet new people.

2
Date of experience: Aug 24, 2025
Deven Fulton
Why When We First Feels Like "They Get Me"

When I first joined When We First, I was excited to try a service that offered a truly personal, human-centered approach to matchmaking. They focus on getting to know you beyond just a profile, pairing you with matches who align with your values, personality, and relationship goals. It felt refreshing to work with a team dedicated to both finding quality matches and helping you grow in the dating process.For the past 7 weeks, I’ve had the pleasure of working with my matchmaker, Claudia. She is warm, kind, and incredibly easy to talk to. From day one, she’s taken the time to understand who I am and what I’m looking for, then thoughtfully explained why each match she presents could be a great fit. Getting matched has been my favorite part of the process. I look forward to hearing her describe the women she’s found for me and the character qualities she sees aligning between us.So far, I’ve been matched with two amazing women—one where I had a fantastic first date, and another with a date coming up soon. Along the way, Claudia has also been an incredible coach, helping me shift from putting early pressure on myself and my matches to simply enjoying the connection and letting things develop naturally. She often reminds me of my strengths, from being a respectful gentleman to a creative, romantic, and fun guy to go on a date with. Plus, she encourages me to bring my authentic self into every interaction.When We First has been a genuinely fun, growth-filled experience, and I’m grateful for how intentional and encouraging Claudia has been in this journey. I look forward to where our partnership together could lead.

5
Date of experience: Aug 11, 2025
Elizabeth Taglang
Sheri has been incredible to work with

Sheri has been incredible to work with. She's kind, thoughtful in her questions, and really respectful of the process. She made everything feel easy and natural. 10/10 I'd recommend her to anyone looking to find a meaningful connection. 🤍Ask ChatGPT

5
Date of experience: Jul 23, 2025
John May
A wonderful experience and different…

A wonderful experience and different than any other dating platform I’ve tried. My matchmaker Sheri has been a delight. Very helpful and engaging throughout the whole process. I would highly recommend When We First to anyone looking to find their person.

5
Date of experience: Jul 13, 2025
Eric
Sheri is amazing!

Sheri is amazing! She is thorough, really gets to know you and what you are looking for in a partner. Once I found someone, she was extremely supportive and provided helpful advice on how to navigate a new relationship. She has been a huge support helping me navigate a new chapter in my life.

5
Date of experience: Jul 02, 2025
Shannon
Valuable coaching

I’d highly recommend Sheri to folks navigating the early days of a new relationship and making sense of their thoughts over time as the relationship evolves. Checking in with her for coaching each week has been really meaningful. It’s helpful to have an expert and outside listening ear and thought partner who can ask thoughtful questions and create a safe place to explore my thoughts and feelings, especially since there’s no concern that she’ll then see my partner and I in regular life and be biased by anything I shared (like a friend or family member might). I’m really grateful to have the dedicated and consistent time to check in, think, and talk about the relationship in a different way than I would on my own. Especially for some of the more challenging things to process as the relationship develops, Sheri has been really supportive and offered exceptional guidance. She has great energy and is very positive, funny, and thoughtful. I’ve had a wonderful experience with her and am so grateful for her coaching as I navigate a new and deeply personal and meaningful experience.

5
Date of experience: Jul 01, 2025
Alise
High End Matchmaking

I worked with Sheri. From the first interview, she took the time to ask insightful, curated questions grounded in emotional intelligence and a deep understanding of compatibility. The company is new, and I heard that only selected individuals were invited to be part of their exclusive network. Sheri was always available and attentive on the follow-up calls. I highly recommend them to anyone looking for a matchmaking service. Worth it

5
Date of experience: Jun 20, 2025

Is this your business?

Claim your business profile now and gain access to all features and respond to customer reviews.

Business Details

  • When We First is a modern dating platform that was developed by a matchmaker to help customers date better both online and offline.

    Matchmaking is at the heart of what we do, and we believe that technology and the human element combined can revolutionize the dating industry one intentional match at a time.

    Whether you’re looking for fun first dates, a long term relationship, marriage, or just a better way to date When We First has your dating life covered and supported. See more

  • email Info@whenwefirst.com
  • call 18337735403
  • language https://whenwefirst.com

We use cookies to personalize your experience. By continuing to visit this website you agree to our use of cookies

More