Name: mysteryshirtinabox.com
Telephone: 000000000
Rating: 3.4

Colm Hardiman Guest

The shirts are either screen printed fakes or the teams they send you are so far down the divisions

The shirts are either screen printed fakes or the teams they send you are so far down the divisions they can’t afford to have embroidered crest badges.
You could buy these shirts for 10 quid on a market stall in Spain.
Specifically asked for only top division teams on my second order: last chance saloon! Was ignored.
Don’t waste your time and money here.

Date of experience: Feb 27, 2026

Johnson Turner Guest

1 month ago

A Thrilling Surprise with Quality Tops

Both of us were aware that ordering was a bit of a gamble. After trying various companies with their mystery tops, I can confidently say this service ranks among the best. The tops we received are of excellent quality, and the designs are both sharp and stylish.

Date of experience: Jan 03, 2026

Diamond Kelly Guest

2 months ago

Unique shirt but slow delivery

The shirt I received was excellent. It was very unique and precisely why I chose to purchase a mystery shirt. Good job on the selection. However, it took an unusually long time to be dispatched, which I found puzzling. I was somewhat disappointed with the delay in shipping and arrival.

Date of experience: Dec 30, 2025

Rendell Rogers Guest

2 months ago

What happened to my order from December 2nd?

What happened to my order from December 2nd? Your website states a 48-hour delivery time, yet I've been waiting for over 20 days! You assured delivery before Christmas... It seems the focus is more on deleting comments and posting on social media than on fulfilling orders. We notice you.

Date of experience: Dec 23, 2025

Alvina Hughes Guest

2 months ago

Order delays and unresponsive support

I ordered three shirts on November 29th with a delivery confirmation of 3-5 days, but I still haven't received my order. The support team is very unresponsive. I've sent several emails and messages through their platform, but there's been no reply.

Date of experience: Dec 12, 2025

DC Guest

2 months ago

Same club received twice

I received two orders, and both times it was the same club's shirt. The selection is quite poor. I will be canceling my subscription.

Date of experience: Dec 12, 2025

Dana Cooper Guest

2 months ago

More memorabilia options needed

Great service as promised, but I'm disappointed with the selection. It seems like mainly items from one specific team and another are not well represented.

Date of experience: Dec 12, 2025

P0lo38 Guest

2 months ago

Fantastic mystery experience

This isn't my first time using the mystery box feature, and I've never been let down. Each shirt is of great quality and sparks conversation when I'm out with friends.

Date of experience: Dec 12, 2025

Chas Cook Guest

2 months ago

Order not received and no email responses

I ordered a Mystery Shirt on November 30th, which was supposed to arrive within 2-3 days. A week later, I still haven't received anything and have emailed and messaged multiple times without any acknowledgment. Very poor customer support.

Date of experience: Dec 11, 2025

Tallulah Guest

2 months ago

Terrible customer service and delivery experience

I placed an order on December 3rd and only received an order confirmation with conflicting delivery times. Eight days later, nothing has arrived, and I've received no communication despite sending two emails and reaching out through the website. Customer service is dreadful, if it even exists.