castelli-newyork.com

2.9
2.9 Based on 14 reviews

...

Unclaimed Profile
Business profile not claimed
This business hasn’t yet claimed their profile on our platform and may be unaware it's listed. As a result, their rating might not fully reflect their customer service or responsiveness.

Average Rating

2.9

/
5

14 Reviews

5 Star
36%
4 Star
14%
3 Star
0%
2 Star
0%
1 Star
50%

All Reviews

Filter Reviews

Review Time

Sanford Smith
Steer clear of this site!

Steer clear of this site! I regret not checking reviews beforehand. As others have pointed out, this company operates from China, and returning items requires you to pay shipping fees to China. The site gives the false impression that the service is U.S.-based.

1
Date of experience: Jan 06, 2026
Canute T.
Avoid ordering from this site

Avoid ordering from this site! I wish I had researched reviews beforehand. As others have mentioned, this company is located in China, and returning items means you'll have to bear the shipping costs to China. The website gives the impression that the service is based in the U.S.

1
Date of experience: Jan 06, 2026
Shayne Reed
Exceptional merchandise quality

The quality of the merchandise is outstanding. The item met my expectations. However, the shirts do run a bit small. I usually wouldn't order an extra large, but in this case, I wish I had. I love the loose fit advertised, but even the large size doesn't fit that way. I’m narrow but busty...

5
Date of experience: Dec 19, 2025
Irene
Warning: potential scam

This is a warning, this company appears to be a significant scam operation based in China. I ordered a vest on December 19th for $69.96 and received an order after 10 days that was nothing like what I had ordered—not in material or design. I emailed to request a return and was told to keep the item and pay 15%, or return it at my own expense to China, which would cost about $50. This feels like a trap where you either accept the 15% loss or face expensive shipping costs. This seems to be a common experience for many, and I plan to report this to the relevant authorities.

1
Date of experience: Dec 19, 2025
Waiizen23
Deceptive company practices

This company is deceptive. The marketing portrays a much higher quality product. When I received my sweater/blazer, it was clear that it was not what I ordered. The fabric was flimsy and the fit was not as advertised. I started the return process but had to email for instructions since none were provided. I was responsible for the return shipping to China, which cost as much as the sweater itself. It doesn't make sense to pay such a high return fee, so I ended up keeping it and donating it. Avoid this company; it’s a scam.

1
Date of experience: Dec 08, 2025
Winnifred
Very satisfied with my purchase

I am very satisfied with my purchase. It is comfortable and exceeded my expectations.

4
Date of experience: Dec 06, 2025
XaraenDream
Dishonest site

This site is dishonest with high prices and questionable practices. I ordered a jacket in November, and as of December 8, I have received no updates and no jacket. Beware; this merchandise comes from China, although they do not disclose this. Shortly after ordering the jacket, I received two sweaters that lack any designer labels and the medium size is much too large. I wanted to exchange them for smalls, but the response I got suggested I keep the sweaters and they would send smalls. Why would I want to keep them? Alternatively, I could receive a 15% refund and pay almost $40 to return them. This is outrageous! Their website claims items ship from New York, but that's false. They need to be shut down. Additionally, the packaging suggested a U.S. warehouse address, so why am I facing international return fees? Stay away from this company. I finally received the jacket, and it is of poor quality and nothing like the images. Please, do your research and avoid similar situations.

1
Date of experience: Dec 03, 2025
Stacy P.
Poor quality and dishonest practices

The clothing designs and quality shown on the site do not match what was shipped. It feels like a fraudulent site, and customer service is non-existent when it comes to processing returns. It’s very disappointing! Don’t fall for it!

1
Date of experience: Nov 28, 2025
Hunter Parker
Scam site with poor quality products

This site is a scam with overpriced items and cheap quality merchandise. They are based in China, and the products are poorly made. What you see on their site is not what you get—a total scam. If you want to return items, be prepared for another scam; they misrepresent their return policy and expect you to cover shipping back to China.

1
Date of experience: Nov 28, 2025
Ines Hansen
Everything turned out well

5
Date of experience: Nov 20, 2025

We use cookies to personalize your experience. By continuing to visit this website you agree to our use of cookies

More