goldbelly.com

1.7
1.7 Based on 190 reviews

Goldbelly is a curated online marketplace for regional and artisanal foods crafted by local food purveyors throughout the United States....

Unclaimed Profile
Business profile not claimed
This business hasn’t yet claimed their profile on our platform and may be unaware it's listed. As a result, their rating might not fully reflect their customer service or responsiveness.

Average Rating

1.7

/
5

190 Reviews

5 Star
13%
4 Star
5%
3 Star
1%
2 Star
7%
1 Star
75%

All Reviews

Filter Reviews

Review Time

Robert Bieber
Ordered king cakes for multiple (3) office locations with the delivery set for Fat Tuesday. One cak

Ordered king cakes for multiple (3) office locations with the delivery set for Fat Tuesday. One cake was delivered midday to one office, while another cake was delivered an hour before that location closed for the day, and certainly after the Mardi Gras festivities at that location. Third cake delivered to an office AFTER THE OFFICE CLOSED FOR THE DAY. BUYER BEWARE: If you need a time-sensitive delivery, DO NOT USE Goldbelly as their "trusted delivery partner" UPS CANNOT be TRUSTED to deliver timely.

1
Date of experience: Feb 17, 2026
Increase Johnson
Disappointing experience after years of loyalty

I have relied on this service for years and have always been satisfied. This year, we decided to send my elderly in-laws a gift of bagels and lox for their Christmas brunch with neighbors. Unfortunately, only the bagels arrived. The lox, cream cheese, capers, tomatoes, and onions were missing. The company believes a $25 credit resolves the issue, but I will not be using their service again.

1
Date of experience: Jan 09, 2026
Jordie Brooks
Confusing Charges and Delayed Orders

I ordered a cake, but it arrived much later than expected. I noticed an unfamiliar charge on my bank statement exceeding $100. When I contacted support, they couldn't identify the charge, even after I provided transaction details. I'm very dissatisfied with how this situation has been handled.

1
Date of experience: Jan 09, 2026
Edward Parker
Unacceptable Customer Service

I reached out to management after ordering two cakes for my son's birthday, only to find they were returned to the sender. I tried contacting support multiple times, but received no response. When I finally got a reply, I was told that all sales are final despite not receiving my order. I'm on the verge of filing complaints with regulators and sharing my concerns with local businesses affected by their mishandling. This experience has been incredibly frustrating.

1
Date of experience: Jan 03, 2026
Sammy H.
Extremely Poor Experience

I ordered a gift for my dad for Christmas, but the shipment was delayed until Dec 30th, which is unacceptable for perishable items. No one answers the phone, and their automated help system is useless. Emails take 2-4 days for a response, which is not acceptable. When I finally asked for a refund, I was told to wait for a senior representative to contact me, but I haven't heard back. I'm left feeling ignored and would advise looking elsewhere.

1
Date of experience: Jan 02, 2026
April Howard
Caution: Spoiled Food and Poor Service

Caution! I ordered a brisket and sausages to be delivered two days before New Year's dinner, but they arrived three days late and spoiled. When I reached out to the service for a refund, I was informed that they were not responsible once the item shipped. Their customer service was unhelpful, only offering a credit. I had to involve the BBB for arbitration and couldn't leave negative reviews due to their lack of a storefront. This company is not trustworthy, and I cannot recommend them unless you want to risk your money.

1
Date of experience: Jan 02, 2026
Dick Cook
Avoid This Service

I ordered bagels through this service, but they arrived in an uninsulated box and were partially thawed. The bagels were hard and stale. I reached out for assistance but received no reply, forcing me to escalate through PayPal for a refund. I recommend contacting the restaurant directly instead for a better experience.

1
Date of experience: Dec 31, 2025
Berenice Ross
Very Disappointing Delivery

I had a terrible experience with my order here. I paid for home delivery but was asked to drive 45 minutes to pick it up. The packaging was inadequate, and the contents were not as advertised. I paid a significant amount for a small quantity of subpar items. This was a complete disappointment!

1
Date of experience: Dec 30, 2025
Raymond P.
Delicious Pies!

I just received my two chocolate chip pies! They're absolutely the best pies I've ever tasted!

5
Date of experience: Dec 30, 2025
PizzaFire467
Late and Stale Delivery

I received my apple cake nine days late, and it was leaking under the packaging. The cake was stale and even had hair on it. After eating a slice, I felt sick. I can't believe customer service thought it was still safe to consume after such poor handling during delivery.

1
Date of experience: Dec 27, 2025

Is this your business?

Claim your business profile now and gain access to all features and respond to customer reviews.

Business Details

  • Goldbelly is a curated online marketplace for regional and artisanal foods crafted by local food purveyors throughout the United States.

  • language https://www.goldbelly.com

We use cookies to personalize your experience. By continuing to visit this website you agree to our use of cookies

More