mastersofmystery.com

4.7
4.7 Based on 541 reviews

...

Unclaimed Profile
Business profile not claimed
This business hasn’t yet claimed their profile on our platform and may be unaware it's listed. As a result, their rating might not fully reflect their customer service or responsiveness.

Average Rating

4.7

/
5

541 Reviews

5 Star
87%
4 Star
4%
3 Star
1%
2 Star
1%
1 Star
6%

All Reviews

Filter Reviews

Review Time

Benji Hoy
The mystery had typos and the medieval font chosen for the scrolls is very hard to read. The mystery

The mystery had typos and the medieval font chosen for the scrolls is very hard to read. The mystery involves making the guests decode scrolls using an A-Z cipher key. This is not only tedious, but pointless, as all the scrolls say roughly the same thing (vague warnings of doom) and don't help solve the mystery. The killer can change, but the clues are always the same, ergo the clues are useless. I bought this mystery for a birthday party, and ended up buying one from a different company.

1
Date of experience: Feb 24, 2026
Whitney Black
I’ve gotten quite a few games from Masters Of Mystery and have loved all of them! I like that each k

I’ve gotten quite a few games from Masters Of Mystery and have loved all of them! I like that each kit comes with EVERYTHING you need and that I can join in as the host. I also appreciate all the extras on the website that help me plan a party (recipes, links to Amazon for decorations, and playlists)! I will forever be a returning customer.

5
Date of experience: Feb 15, 2026
Robert Bremmer
First, Masters of Mystery responded immediately and I received the digital game right away. Secondly

First, Masters of Mystery responded immediately and I received the digital game right away. Secondly, once you download and save the files, you can easily customize the invitations, character profiles, and introductions.
Third, the audio introductions per round are excellent. However, as a suggestion to consider, you might want to have your group view an actual Bridgerton episode, so they really get the hang of what they are dealing with and it would greatly help the uninformed

5
Date of experience: Jan 28, 2026
An Unforgettable Murder Mystery Experience

I purchased a murder mystery kit for my daughter's 18th birthday celebration. I facilitated the game for her and her seven friends. Everyone came dressed in character for a D&D-themed party, so the murder announcement caught everyone off guard. The instructions were straightforward, and everyone thoroughly enjoyed themselves. The characters were entertaining and engaging. I was especially pleased that the game includes a numbering system for the murderer, allowing any character to take on that role, meaning we can reuse it multiple times, even with the same group. Although I haven't organized another gathering yet, I look forward to hosting one for my peers. I highly recommend this service; they have clearly invested effort into ensuring a fantastic experience! I've shared my recommendation with many, and a recent visit to their site revealed they have added more games, which I'm eager to explore.

5
Date of experience: Jan 23, 2026
Cora
An unforgettable experience with our murder mystery event!

We had an amazing time with our murder mystery. We chose a thrilling theme for a friend's birthday celebration. Each segment of the mystery unfolded at a different eerie venue, making it even more exciting. Planning and organizing this for our group of 12 was quite straightforward. I would definitely consider doing another one.

5
Date of experience: Jan 07, 2026
An all-inclusive digital murder mystery experience

The digital murder mystery package provided everything I needed, from menu suggestions and recipes (which I still use frequently), to costume inspirations, and even a Spotify playlist to create the perfect atmosphere. I couldn't imagine anything else that could have been included. As a first-time host, I found all the instructions incredibly straightforward.

5
Date of experience: Jan 06, 2026
Rhonda Brooks
Fantastic Experience with Masters of Mystery Games!

I have tried three Masters of Mystery games: 1920's, 1980's, and Christmas Murder Mashup. My guests and I had an incredible time with each one! As long as you go through the host guide before starting, it’s quite simple. The characters and scripts are hilarious, and dressing up adds to the fun. Highly recommend!

5
Date of experience: Jan 05, 2026
Tommie Johnson
Fantastic experience! Clear character guides enhance the fun for all

We truly enjoyed ourselves! The clear guides for each character made the game accessible and enjoyable for everyone. Many in our group were professional actors, but it was also great for those without that background. When we encountered a hiccup with the casting, the support team assisted us beyond our expectations. We definitely plan to return for more. (And keep an eye out for that Captain Studley!)

5
Date of experience: Dec 09, 2025
Timmy Morris
Absolutely thrilled with these murder mystery kits!

I can't speak highly enough about these murder mystery kits! From the moment we opened the package, it felt like we were diving into our very own thrilling case. The writing is sharp, the clues are cleverly designed without being overly difficult, and every twist had us eagerly sharing theories across the room. Each game immerses you in a completely unique setting. One moment you’re embodying a detective in a foggy Victorian street, and the next you’re discovering secrets in a bizarre new world. The attention to detail is outstanding. Even the character descriptions had us laughing, gasping, and fully embracing our roles. What impressed me the most was the perfect balance throughout the experience. The puzzles are challenging yet reasonable, the pacing keeps everyone engaged, and there are numerous delightful secrets waiting to be revealed. Our group included both total beginners and puzzle enthusiasts, and by the end of the night, everyone was completely captivated. We’ve already ordered our next game. These kits are truly exceptional. If you’re even slightly considering a murder mystery night, don’t hesitate—just get one. It will provide you with the most enjoyable time you’ve had in a long while.

4
Date of experience: Dec 06, 2025
Teresa
Incredible Experience for a Birthday Celebration!

I organized a mystery event for my husband’s birthday, and over 14 guests attended, all of whom had an amazing time! The provided scripts were extremely helpful, and everyone really embraced their roles! The game was straightforward to follow. I also appreciated that I, as the host, could participate in the fun instead of just managing everything. I will definitely consider this service for my next murder mystery event! A special mention for having a guide to assist with so many players—that was a key reason for choosing this option! 👍

5
Date of experience: Dec 06, 2025

We use cookies to personalize your experience. By continuing to visit this website you agree to our use of cookies

More