papayastickers.com

3.7
3.7 Based on 6 reviews

...

Unclaimed Profile
Business profile not claimed
This business hasn’t yet claimed their profile on our platform and may be unaware it's listed. As a result, their rating might not fully reflect their customer service or responsiveness.

Average Rating

3.7

/
5

6 Reviews

5 Star
67%
4 Star
0%
3 Star
0%
2 Star
0%
1 Star
33%

All Reviews

Filter Reviews

Review Time

Briana Gomez
Ordered stickers, expected them to come in by a certain time, they seemed to not be, I reached out t

Ordered stickers, expected them to come in by a certain time, they seemed to not be, I reached out to share my concerns, they immediately shipped my stickers in express carrier and they DID get here in time for my event. Amazing for me honestly, thank you so much!

Stickers came out great for me too, good quality.

5
Date of experience: Feb 04, 2026
Briana Gomez
Ordered stickers

Ordered stickers, expected them to come in by a certain time, they seemed to not be, I reached out to share my concerns, they immediately shipped my stickers in express carrier and they DID get here in time for my event. Amazing for me honestly, thank you so much!Stickers came out great for me too, good quality.

5
Date of experience: Jan 29, 2026
Mel Dunn
They took my money and ran

They took my money and ran. I think this company is a scam. Haven’t heard Jack diddly squat from their “support” team.

1
Date of experience: Dec 02, 2025
Scam

Firstly, Papaya is operated by Atomic Signs, who also offer stickers through their legit site and are in my opinion an out-and-out scam. I'd speculate that Papaya is a front because they burned too many customers as Atomic. I fell for it. I had ordered from Atomic, got sent the wrong item, was told I was SOL because they didn't have enough staff to operate, so I filed a chargeback and got my money back. Ordered from Papaya, got send a proof of multiple designs. Most were good, one was wonky. Asked them to fix the wonky one. Papaya sends a new proof where all the colours are severely distorted. I ask, can I get them like the first proof and just fix the wonky one? Get told, no, we sent you that proof but we're actually not willing or able to honour it, our printer can't print those colours. I guess if I hadn't rejected the first proof they would have sent me their terrible looking "edits" anyways without consulting me? Great. We go back and forth where it seems like they're deliberately making the designs look worse and worse. I used like 3 colours across all my designs and none of the proofs they send aside from the first one they refuse to honour even have the colours match from one design to the next. So I asked for my money back and they did refund me. Just an absolute waste of time.Funny how they have time to send several long messages a day side-stepping the question of why the first proof was ever sent if they knew they had no intent or ability to honour it, and yet Atomic "doesn't have enough staff" to have operational customer service

1
Date of experience: Oct 29, 2025
Israel K.
Love the product and their service.

Love the product and their service.

5
Date of experience: Jul 08, 2025
Herman Bell
New Company, Product Excellent, Customer Service Excellent

My first order from PapayaStickers.com was fantastic — the stickers arrived on time and looked even better than expected. I was so happy, I placed a second order right away.There was a bit of confusion and a delay with the second order, and communication was initially lacking. But after reaching out, I received a personal phone call from someone at Papaya. They were friendly, apologetic, and explained that they’re a brand-new company working through some growing pains. They even offered a discount to make up for the inconvenience.It was a great recovery, and I really appreciated the effort. The sticker quality is excellent, and I’m cheering them on as they continue to grow!

5
Date of experience: Apr 05, 2025

We use cookies to personalize your experience. By continuing to visit this website you agree to our use of cookies

More