butcherboxforpets.com

4.3
4.3 Based on 23 reviews

...

Unclaimed Profile
Business profile not claimed
This business hasn’t yet claimed their profile on our platform and may be unaware it's listed. As a result, their rating might not fully reflect their customer service or responsiveness.

Average Rating

4.3

/
5

23 Reviews

5 Star
75%
4 Star
8%
3 Star
0%
2 Star
4%
1 Star
13%

All Reviews

Filter Reviews

Review Time

Tonya Wilson
Surprisingly Satisfied with the Trial Package

My Buddy is notoriously picky when it comes to food, yet he polished off the trial package without hesitation. It was the first time I saw him lick his bowl clean! I would have rated it 5 stars, but I'm still in the trial phase.

4
Date of experience: Dec 27, 2025
My extreme picky eater loves this food

My extreme picky eater loves this food. I really appreciate the sourcing too!

5
Date of experience: Sep 17, 2025
itang
🚫 NEVER GET BUTCHERBOX 🚫

🚫 NEVER GET BUTCHERBOX 🚫🚫 NEVER GET BUTCHERBOX 🚫This company is unsafe, deceptive, and irresponsible. Their chicken mix food caused confirmed food poisoning in my dogs. In another shipment, I found a jagged bone in the beef mix. Their customer service is slow and dismissive. And their cancelation button does not work — which is unlawful under Virginia law (§ 59.1-207.46).Here’s the full story:I originally purchased ButcherBox for my 6-month-old, 10-lb miniature Poodle puppy (Tony Stark).The first shipment of beef mix contained a jagged bone larger than a quarter. The company’s response was appalling: “Since our meals are made with fresh meat, on rare occasions a small bone fragment may appear…” As if a jagged bone in food meant for a puppy is acceptable. It is dangerous and reckless.Because their cancelation button does not work (in violation of Virginia law requiring an easy online option), I couldn’t stop another box from shipping. On 9/17, I fed the chicken mix from that box only to my two Standard Poodles, Bruce Wayne and JoolZ. Both were diagnosed with food poisoning at the emergency vet. The puppy, who did not eat the food, remained well. I incurred vet bills, endured four sleepless nights letting them outside every 45 minutes, and then threw out the rest of the food — nearly $200 in the trash — but worth it to protect my dogs.I contacted the company on September 9th. They didn’t provide a final response until September 22nd after 9:00 pm — nearly two weeks later and only after multiple follow-ups, while another box had already shipped.Their so-called resolution was outrageous and unconscionable. They reimbursed only the first box under their “satisfaction guarantee” (not even because of the jagged bone) and refused to reimburse the second box that directly caused food poisoning and emergency vet expenses.I am a Registered Dietitian with SafeServ certification. I know food safety. I’ve been preparing fresh food for my dogs since 2008, following proper storage and thawing practices. This was not mishandling — this was ButcherBox’s unsafe food and deceptive support.Their food made my dogs sick. Their excuses were egregious. Their cancellation process is unlawful.No responsible company should operate this way — and no pet owner should ever trust ButcherBox with their animals’ health.

1
Date of experience: Sep 09, 2025
Lynnette
So far so good!

So far so good! They are loving it and I appreciate the sourcing. I couldn't get NomNom to tell me country of origin, nor would they confirm no growth hormones or antibiotics so we were grateful for an alternative.

5
Date of experience: Aug 18, 2025
Jimmy Carter
Licks the bowl clean

I ordered this for my Chihuahua mix and he likes it. I was spending a good part of my day off making his food from scratch. This frees up some time. I will continue to add extra vegetables and other things to add more nutrients.

4
Date of experience: Aug 14, 2025
SP14
terrible service; order missing 10lbs of food.

worst customer service ever. Good luck getting a response. I just switched to fresh-food for my dog, and the first order I received seems to have been a full 10lbs short of what I paid-for.

1
Date of experience: Jul 14, 2025
Koolskys77
Customer service is sh!tty

Customer service is sh!tty, at best but it's actually nonexistent. There's no phone number and they never answer emails. Food is definitely not the best (at leastbased on my dogs' teactions to it and Pooty eats EVERYTHING) , especially for the price.All adds up to pricey, dogs' "meh" reaction, and nonexistent customer service. There are far better options: Pet Plate, Ollie, Nom Nom, Pet's Table, Spot and Tango, Sundays, We Feed Raw [they now have freeze dried raw. Pooty and Ebby love it], etc...). All have cheaper options and actual customer service.

1
Date of experience: Jun 19, 2025
First order was a hit

First order was a hit! My old girl devours her wet food; even used as a topper, she usually eats all of her kibble, too. So far I am pleased with everything about Butcherbox for Pets.

5
Date of experience: Jun 07, 2025
Jasmine Clark
GREAT food

GREAT food, dogs love it, cannot get anyone to answer an email and there is NO PHONE NUMBER listed. I even called butcher box where we get our meat and they said they are completely unrelated except by name. I have been emailing for over 5 days and so now I am leaving a review because maybe someone will respond. first order was great second order MIA and no one responds, Will be sad to cancel but I will if I cannot get some help

2
Date of experience: May 31, 2025
Velvet Long
Ollie eats it right up!

Ollie is a “take it or leave it” kind of dog. He really takes this food!! He eats it right up!!

5
Date of experience: May 25, 2025

We use cookies to personalize your experience. By continuing to visit this website you agree to our use of cookies

More