overnightdiamonds.com

5
5 Based on 160 reviews

...

Unclaimed Profile
Business profile not claimed
This business hasn’t yet claimed their profile on our platform and may be unaware it's listed. As a result, their rating might not fully reflect their customer service or responsiveness.

Average Rating

5

/
5

160 Reviews

5 Star
99%
4 Star
1%
3 Star
0%
2 Star
0%
1 Star
0%

All Reviews

Filter Reviews

Review Time

Curt Collins
I have purchased several items from Mike over several years. His service, quality of jewelry and kno

I have purchased several items from Mike over several years. His service, quality of jewelry and knowledge is immensely better than any jeweler I have ever dealt with. I would give 6 stars if I could. Give him a call and you will be extremely satisfied!

5
Date of experience: Feb 16, 2026
Lydia
Michael is simply the best!

I’ve worked with Michael and team for over 15 years. The quality, fairness of pricing and professionalism is second to none. His pricing is very fair and he always does what he says he will do. My highest recommendation!

5
Date of experience: Jun 30, 2025
Jemmy
Highly recommend!

We have purchased several pieces of jewelry from Mike over the years, including a diamond ring, diamond earrings, and a few other pieces. He is incredibly responsive, offers great advice when it comes to selecting stones or providing general guidance, and his prices are very competitive. We will continue to purchase from McGivern Diamonds in the future, and would highly recommend him to anyone!

5
Date of experience: Jun 10, 2025
KF48
Absolutely thrilled with my experience at McGivern Diamonds!

Mike McGivern was an absolute pleasure to work with—friendly, incredibly knowledgeable, and patient throughout the entire process. He answered all of my questions promptly and thoroughly, making me feel confident every step of the way. My custom-made diamond ring is nothing short of perfect—it's even more beautiful than I had imagined. I couldn't be happier!

5
Date of experience: May 30, 2025
MrDemoniak46
McGivern Diamonds has had my family’s…

McGivern Diamonds has had my family’s business and loyalty for 10 years now. My husband had my engagement ring made here, I chose my bands from here, Mike made my anniversary band at five years, and as I come up on 10 years my new ring will also be from here! We have recommended McGivern’s several times and have never heard a complaint! Customer service and communication is top notch!

5
Date of experience: Jan 03, 2025
Percy Wilson
McGivern is THE best!

I’ve purchased a few items from McGivern - loose stones, as well as custom-made earrings. Everything is always stunning! The quality of stones & craftsmanship, and the honest & quick customer service from Mike, are all unmatched. Other jewelers have even commented on how lovely my diamond ring is, because the stone from McGivern is so beautiful. Recommend 100%!

5
Date of experience: Dec 16, 2024
Sigmund Barnes
Best experience!

Michael and his team were wonderful to work with! They were patient and showed us many options over a two week period. We couldn't be more pleased with the rings, the extraordinary service and the entire experience! They are now our jeweler!

5
Date of experience: Oct 21, 2024
Summer
Michael was great to work and I had so…

Michael was great to work and I had so much trust in him, especially working with him over the phone/email. My husband bought my engagement ring 24 years ago and I just had Michael recreate my setting with a few changes. He did a fabulous job! Dealing with Michael was relaxing with no pressure and he truly cares about his customers! Thank you Michael for a job well done!

5
Date of experience: Sep 26, 2024
Bud Morris
4th purchase spanning 30 years!

I made my first purchase from McGivern's in the mid-1990's - my wife's wedding ring. Mike just completed her 30th anniversary band which he custom made for her. This is my fourth purchase from McGivern's and I have never been anything but elated with Mike's service and diamond quality. He is as talented as he is trustworthy.

5
Date of experience: Jun 28, 2024
Kermit Bell
I’ve been a McGivern customer for over…20 years

I’ve been a McGivern customer for over 20 years; I’ve never had less than an extraordinary experience. The difference between a family owned business and other business types is never more obvious. The owner Michael sold me my wife’s engagement ring 20 years ago and the matching band this month; and there have been other diamond purchases in between.His judgement is flawless; often pointing me to a lower price stone that he felt offered greater value. Find that at Zales!William RohrbachDenville, NJ

5
Date of experience: May 11, 2024

We use cookies to personalize your experience. By continuing to visit this website you agree to our use of cookies

More