coinfully.com

4.9
4.9 Based on 161 reviews

...

Unclaimed Profile
Business profile not claimed
This business hasn’t yet claimed their profile on our platform and may be unaware it's listed. As a result, their rating might not fully reflect their customer service or responsiveness.

Average Rating

4.9

/
5

161 Reviews

5 Star
94%
4 Star
2%
3 Star
2%
2 Star
0%
1 Star
2%

All Reviews

Filter Reviews

Review Time

Andrew Leisewitz
Great service

It was quick; what was advertised was what happened. They did not over promise and under deliver - what they promised, they delivered.

5
Date of experience: Oct 22, 2025
John Dunderdale
Matt and Trip were both amazing and…

Matt and Trip were both amazing and made me feel comfortable during the transaction. At first, I was suspicious and skeptical but after talking to Matt and Trip, they showed they were honest and truthful. Coinfully is an honest company and treats you fair and upfront.

5
Date of experience: Oct 22, 2025
George
Coinfully representatives couldn’t have…

Coinfully representatives couldn’t have been more professional and helpful! Very easy to work with and very satisfied customer and will do more business with them.

5
Date of experience: Oct 22, 2025
Dave Parr
Extreme lowball?

I sent pics of 1936-40 proof sets. They said "the value of these coins would total about $196." I then called a coin shop in Phoenix and their estimate for the 1936 set only was about $4k. Am I missing something here?

1
Date of experience: Oct 20, 2025
customer
Great experience! Highly recommend!

My experience with Coinfully was top notch!!! I sent them a printed list of coins and that same day received an offer. After a quick phone call and when we were in agreement, they forwarded a document for my signature and directions for packing. Sent the next day and quickly received my check through email along with shipping reimbursement. Such a smooth transaction! I highly recommend this company! 5 stars!

5
Date of experience: Oct 15, 2025
Gina C.
A Company to Trust

For me, the honesty and transparency really were impressive. With so much deception online, as a senior, I was a bit dubious. However, from start to finish, they kept in contact, provided quick service and offered a better price than anyone locally. Finally, this senior cashed her first e-check with no problem whatsoever. Honest, fair, friendly. My kind of company.

5
Date of experience: Oct 15, 2025
G. Warren
Very quick and professional company

Very quick and professional company. Kept in high contact, helpful, and no nonsense. Would do business with them again in a second.

5
Date of experience: Oct 09, 2025
Bill Singer
Felt I was dealing with an honest…

Felt I was dealing with an honest company. Very professional. Could you get more elsewhere? Maybe. I was completely happy with everything.

5
Date of experience: Sep 12, 2025
Adam Pingot
Very easy to work with

Very easy to work with. They kept in contact with me throughout and were quick to respond whenever I contacted them. The payment i received came the same day they received my coins. I highly recommend their services.

5
Date of experience: Sep 12, 2025
Mark Anderson
Coinfully was a pleasure to work with

Coinfully was a pleasure to work with. After reaching out to them online, they called and had a personal conversation with me. Based on some pictures that I sent and our conversation, they came to my house to evaluate my collection personally. During the visit, they were very helpful in informing me about my coins and what they were looking at specifically. At the end of the visit (about 3 hours), they gave me a detailed evaluation and value of the collection, and made me a very fair offer for the collection.One coin in particular they separated out for grading. This coin was not included in the initial evaluation. They sent it out for grading. When it came back as authentic and with a grade, they clearly explained my options (auction, hold on to it, or they would buy it). Again, they gave me a very fair price that they would buy it at.Overall, I was impressed with how responsive and helpful Coinfully was in helping me understand my collection. They were extremely professional, and communicated with me (email, phone, in person) throughout the entire process of evaluating my collection. Mathew was the person that I interacted with from the start, and he was a pleasure to work with.My experience was excellent, and I would highly recommend Coinfully.

5
Date of experience: Sep 11, 2025

We use cookies to personalize your experience. By continuing to visit this website you agree to our use of cookies

More