plymouthrock.com

1.3
1.3 Based on 20 reviews

Plymouth Rock Assurance offers quick insurance quotes and coverage options for your auto, home, motorcycle, boat, and more. Get a quote online today!...

Unclaimed Profile
Business profile not claimed
This business hasn’t yet claimed their profile on our platform and may be unaware it's listed. As a result, their rating might not fully reflect their customer service or responsiveness.

Average Rating

1.3

/
5

20 Reviews

5 Star
5%
4 Star
0%
3 Star
0%
2 Star
5%
1 Star
90%

All Reviews

Filter Reviews

Review Time

Frustrating experience with policy cancellation

I attempted to cancel my policy on 11/28/2025, but the office was closed. I received an email confirming the closure and a follow-up from a representative the next day. I managed to cancel on 11/29/2025, but I was never informed that my payment would still be processed. On 12/3, they withdrew $197.58 from my account, leading to an overdraft. The representatives provided inconsistent information, referenced an outdated agreement I was not reminded of, and mentioned that refunds could take 30–60 days. This situation highlights negligence, poor communication, and questionable practices. I strongly advise others to think twice before engaging with this company.

1
Date of experience: Dec 07, 2025
Rhiannon Cook
Policy Canceled, Yet Charged – Unacceptable!

I attempted to cancel my policy on 11/28/2025, but the office was closed. I received an email confirming the closure and a response from an employee the following day. I ultimately canceled on 11/29/2025, but was never informed that my payment would still be processed. On 12/3, $197.58 was withdrawn from my account, leading to an overdraft. The service representatives provided conflicting information, referenced an outdated ACH agreement I was unaware of, and stated that refunds could take 30–60 days. This reflects negligence, poor communication, and unethical behavior. I strongly advise others to think twice before using this company.

1
Date of experience: Nov 29, 2025
Dustin Brown
Accurate Reviews – A Cautionary Tale

These reviews are spot on! I just spoke with an agent who still hasn’t reviewed the dash cam footage that the officer mentioned was present, indicating we were both merging. There is no merging on the turnpike when you're in the far left lane! We had to move to the right side of the highway to pull over! I told her that until the dash cam footage from the other driver is reviewed, there’s nothing more to discuss! They also will not be renewing my policy!

1
Date of experience: Oct 16, 2025
zChocolate72
Terrible Experience – Look Elsewhere

This is the worst company I have ever dealt with. I switched to another provider and saved over $400 a month. For the brief period I was insured, I only received an $86 refund from the $559 charged. They seem to have cancellation fees. Additionally, the request for a form from my new provider took several days to process through their agents. I would not recommend this company.

1
Date of experience: Oct 12, 2025
Kailey Foster
Fraudulent Practices!

I would give zero stars if I could. I started my policy at $400 a month, but after renewal, it jumped to $607 without any notice (I’ve never had an accident or even been pulled over). I noticed inconsistencies in my billing, with amounts changing frequently. Every time I reached out, they claimed it was an error, yet nothing was resolved. I even saw reversed transactions after making payments, but the amounts were never credited back to my account. Frustrated, I requested immediate cancellation and mentioned contacting a lawyer. They continued to charge me, adding over $100 a month for homeowners' insurance that I never requested. They sent me a bill for over $2500 despite me not renting or owning a home. This company will take advantage of you! STAY AWAY! Also, they aren't accredited by the BBB.

1
Date of experience: Apr 20, 2025
flogarou47
Disappointing Customer Service

It's quite shocking that this company has insured my home for years without any claims, yet they suddenly decided not to renew my policy. This is incredibly poor business practice and reflects terrible customer service.

1
Date of experience: Mar 26, 2025
Nigel Reed
Avoid This Company

Please, do not even consider signing up with this company; you will end up feeling ripped off and distressed. They seem to have no regard for middle-class customers and will ensure that you are left in a precarious situation.

1
Date of experience: Dec 29, 2024
Roland
Failed Commitments from the Insurance Provider

To provide some context, I have been insured with this company for the past two years, covering four vehicles. On 12/03/24, my car was severely damaged in an accident. After the vehicle was taken to a tow yard and then a body shop, the shop sent them an appraisal for repairs exceeding $20k. The appraiser and adjuster have done nothing with that information, dragging their feet while I received an email stating I need to return my rental in four days. This experience has been extremely stressful, especially given the high premiums I pay without receiving the service I expected. I cannot recommend this insurance to anyone.

1
Date of experience: Dec 27, 2024
Extremely Frustrating Experience

If I could rate this company lower than one star, I would. My car was parked, and I found damage to it upon my return. The company claims I backed into something to avoid surcharges. The damage is estimated at around $3000 on a $90,000 vehicle. After three adjusters, a forensic team, and two months of investigation—likely costing more than the repairs—they issued a check to the repair shop, only to change their minds and tell them not to cash it. They cited several 'internal mistakes' made by their office. This situation seems very questionable and warrants investigation. I pay my premiums in full for all my vehicles.

1
Date of experience: Nov 01, 2024
Patrick
Disappointed by Recent Policy Changes

As a loyal customer for several years, I maintained my policy with zero claims and always paid on time. Historically, the company conducted home assessments, but they recently shifted this responsibility to customers as a self-service task. I was unaware of this new requirement and missed completing the assessment. Despite my loyalty and clean claim record, the company decided to drop my coverage due to this oversight. This decision seems to prioritize cost-cutting over customer service. It’s disheartening to see a long-term relationship dismissed over a procedural change that was not clearly communicated. If you’re considering this company for your insurance needs, be cautious; they may prioritize profits over client loyalty. I am very disappointed and now seeking a provider who values their customers and communicates effectively.

1
Date of experience: Aug 13, 2024

Is this your business?

Claim your business profile now and gain access to all features and respond to customer reviews.

Business Details

  • Plymouth Rock Assurance offers quick insurance quotes and coverage options for your auto, home, motorcycle, boat, and more. Get a quote online today!

  • call 8005169242
  • language https://plymouthrock.com

We use cookies to personalize your experience. By continuing to visit this website you agree to our use of cookies

More