classicauthentics.com

4.2
4.2 Based on 20 reviews

...

Unclaimed Profile
Business profile not claimed
This business hasn’t yet claimed their profile on our platform and may be unaware it's listed. As a result, their rating might not fully reflect their customer service or responsiveness.

Average Rating

4.2

/
5

20 Reviews

5 Star
68%
4 Star
0%
3 Star
0%
2 Star
0%
1 Star
32%

All Reviews

Filter Reviews

Review Time

Gabbie Aguirre
DO NOT ORDER FROM HERE!!! This is the most unprofessional “ business” I’ve ever dealt with this Anth

DO NOT ORDER FROM HERE!!! This is the most unprofessional “ business” I’ve ever dealt with this Anthony Argo is claiming that the bad reviews are from another China based facility, but they’re not it’s this classic authentic website when I was just inquiring about my order I was cussed at and then was sent an empty bag!!! ANTHONY ARGO IS A SCAMMER BEWARE AND ALL THESE POSITIVE REVIEWS ARE MORE THAN LIKELY FROM HIM OR PEOPLE HE KNOWS!!!!

1
Date of experience: Feb 16, 2026
Merrilyn Reed
Outstanding Customer Support Made All the Difference

I want to start by highlighting that the exceptional customer support I received is the reason for my five-star review. I ordered a jersey and anticipated a 2-day delivery, but I overlooked the possibility of a 5-week wait. After reaching out to the support team, I received a call back. Yes, they called me. A representative explained their process and the potential 5-week timeframe, while I expressed my desire for the jersey within 2 days. The representative went above and beyond to find a solution that suited us both. Thanks to the efforts of the team, I’m pleased to say I received my jersey. It’s reassuring to know that a company values its customers and takes the time to resolve issues personally.

5
Date of experience: Jan 09, 2026
Roderick F.
Disappointing experience with order and customer service

I placed an order for a jersey 7 weeks ago, expecting a shipping time of 4-5 weeks. When I contacted the owner for clarification, I encountered rudeness. I've just sent another email inquiring about an estimated arrival time, and I hope to receive a response soon. As a customer, it shouldn't fall on me to chase updates for a delayed order, nor should I have to deal with an unprofessional owner.

1
Date of experience: Dec 26, 2025
Giles A.
FAKE JERSEYS... BE WARNED!!!

FAKE JERSEYS... BE WARNED!!! I ordered an away (white) jersey for my son as a Christmas gift on 11/30/25 with two-day shipping. It arrived 9 days later on December 8. Upon examining the jersey, the red color appeared overly bright, and the stitching did not match the official NFL jersey (there were extra seams in the back, and no mesh lining on the sides). It seems the seller is sourcing knock-offs, inflating the prices, and reselling them for profit. Additionally, there are no return options, leaving me at a loss. Avoid this seller—TOTAL RIPOFF!

1
Date of experience: Dec 11, 2025
Order cancellation within minutes and poor response.

My order was cancelled just 15 minutes after I placed it. My daughter had already bought the same jersey from another source. They wanted to impose a cancellation fee, which I was willing to accept, but I simply requested their legal policy regarding the charge. The reply I received was from a representative stating they would absorb the loss but requested that I not place any future orders with the company... Not an issue at all.

1
Date of experience: Dec 04, 2025
Ellen Clark
Order Cancellation - Poor Customer Service

I canceled my order shortly after placing it, as my daughter had already gotten the same item elsewhere. They wanted to charge a cancellation fee, which I was okay with, but when I requested their policy on this charge, I received an email that was unprofessional. The representative stated they would absorb the loss but asked me not to order from them again, which I have no intention of doing.

1
Date of experience: Dec 04, 2025
Madelyn Taylor
Mistaken Order - Terrible Response

I accidentally placed an order and requested a cancellation just five minutes later. Instead of a simple answer, I received a rude email telling me to 'get it together.' I acknowledged my mistake and simply asked about cancellation, but was met with hostility. They even mentioned dealing with 'idiots like me' as annoying. It’s disappointing that those in customer service lack patience. I've since received voicemails from a manager using offensive language.

1
Date of experience: Nov 24, 2025
Bruno Kelly
Extremely Satisfied with My Purchase

I ordered a sports jersey and chose this service because they advertised stitched numbers and names, unlike other places. I know from experience that heat-applied items can fall apart. The jersey arrived just a week after ordering, and I couldn't be happier. The price was fair, and the quality is exceptional. I noticed some mixed reviews about the owner, but my experience was so positive that I felt compelled to share it. I'm 100% satisfied and will definitely order again.

5
Date of experience: Nov 24, 2025
Nia Hughes
An Outstanding Business!

I found a rare sports jersey for my husband that he has wanted for years. I even found two! They arrived today, and I had to write a review because the quality is excellent for such a reasonable price. The representative was very helpful and responsive. We will certainly be ordering more from this service.

5
Date of experience: Nov 08, 2025
Keith Wright
High-Quality Products

The products are excellent! I ordered three sports jerseys, including two custom ones. They all turned out perfectly, and I can't wait to wear them to a game!

5
Date of experience: Nov 03, 2025

We use cookies to personalize your experience. By continuing to visit this website you agree to our use of cookies

More