newyorktheatreguide.com

4.6
4.6 Based on 622 reviews

...

Unclaimed Profile
Business profile not claimed
This business hasn’t yet claimed their profile on our platform and may be unaware it's listed. As a result, their rating might not fully reflect their customer service or responsiveness.

Average Rating

4.6

/
5

622 Reviews

5 Star
85%
4 Star
4%
3 Star
2%
2 Star
2%
1 Star
7%

Filtered Reviews

Filter Reviews

Review Time

Thomas Guarnera
Great Service!

This is my first experience using NY Theater GuideThe process was seemless, quick and efficient While I would have liked storing the electronic tickets in my Apple Wallet, short of that, I would definitely use this service again.

5
Date of experience: Apr 05, 2026
Kris Gusciora
Ease of Entire Experience

Ease of choices & dates, with clear seating plan and ease of use.Easiest money I’ve spent! 😎

5
Date of experience: Apr 05, 2026
Joleen Bales
Fail by the venue and ticket sales

Fail by the venue and ticket sales. This was our one show while on vacation in NYC as it came recommended by friends and family. We arrived as a family of 4 with our daughter age 20 with her parents and we were not able to attend the event. Very disappointed. Hope we can at least get refunded. Maybe we will try again next year.

1
Date of experience: Apr 04, 2026
Betsy
The seats were not as advertised

The seats were not as advertised. They were in the back of the theater, in chairs that had been clearly added and were not raked. Also next to light/sound booth. These should have been marked as obstructed vision seats!

2
Date of experience: Apr 02, 2026
Theresa E
It was so easy choosing seats and…

It was so easy choosing seats and ordering tickets online. Your website is very user friendly. Can’t wait to visit New York soon and see a play

5
Date of experience: Apr 01, 2026
Top Tier Customer Service!

When I needed help with an issue related to my order, I reached out to customer service. Engaging with customer service can often feel daunting. However, NYTG made the entire experience smooth and stress-free.I was initially skeptical when my first point of contact was an AI bot, but I was pleasantly surprised to be connected to a live representative in under a minute. Within 60 seconds, I was speaking with Cheyenne, who provided exceptional service from start to finish.She was courteous, knowledgeable, and genuinely attentive. She took the time to fully understand my concerns and thoughtfully addressed each one without rushing our interaction. Her patience and willingness to go above and beyond made a big difference.After our conversation ended, I realized I had one more question and had to reach out to them again. By chance, I was connected with Cheyenne once more and she was just as helpful, patient, and efficient the second time around. She quickly got me what I needed and made the process completely painless.Every company needs someone a Cheyenne. While I can’t speak for the entire team, having her as my first point of contact reflects very positively on NYTG and the kind of people they have representing their brand.

5
Date of experience: Apr 01, 2026
customer
Extremely easy to find and purchase our…

Extremely easy to find and purchase our tickets online. The seat view feature was a bonus. Added security in requiring a “handshake” with our payment partner was greatly appreciated in a time when one is never completely sure of what they’re buying through a website.

5
Date of experience: Mar 29, 2026
customer
A very helpful experience!

I had some difficulties with purchasing in the need to exchange. Sam the customer rep was absolutely wonderful! He understood the problem and tried various options. He was very thorough, understanding, and helpful! Unfortunately, there are not a lot of Sam’s in this world of technology, but he was really great. Thank you.

5
Date of experience: Mar 28, 2026
Martin Hillert
I purchased tickets and then learned…

I purchased tickets and then learned that my partner had purchased tickets for the same show on a different day as a birthday surprise for me. It was a wonderful surprise until I discovered that I could not cancel my purchase without giving up 20 percent of the value. Shame on me, I guess; even though the cancellation was less than a day afterThe booking.

2
Date of experience: Mar 27, 2026
Ian T.
Stopped sweating bullets

I had somehow deleted my e-tickets for my late April Broadway show. These tickets are a birthday present for my wife. After an online chat first with the an AI assistant and then with Sam I was sent a new email confirmation of my e-tickets. Thank you Sam I am no longer sweating bullets.

5
Date of experience: Mar 25, 2026

We use cookies to personalize your experience. By continuing to visit this website you agree to our use of cookies

More