sarahelisejewelry.com

3.7
3.7 Based on 101 reviews

We work with 14k, 18k solid gold set with high quality hand cut gemstones and ethically sourced natural full cut diamonds....

Unclaimed Profile
Business profile not claimed
This business hasn’t yet claimed their profile on our platform and may be unaware it's listed. As a result, their rating might not fully reflect their customer service or responsiveness.

Average Rating

3.7

/
5

101 Reviews

5 Star
63%
4 Star
4%
3 Star
2%
2 Star
3%
1 Star
28%

Filtered Reviews

Filter Reviews

Review Time

Michael Sanchez
I got an engagement ring from Sarah Elsie Jewelry and the whole process was way easier than I expect

I got an engagement ring from Sarah Elsie Jewelry and the whole process was way easier than I expected. We did everything over email, and they were super responsive and helpful the entire time. I had a lot of questions, but they made it feel simple and stress-free. Couldn’t be happier with how it all turned out.

5
Date of experience: Mar 21, 2026
Songul Ekici
Had such a great experience with Sarah…

Had such a great experience with Sarah Elsie Jewelry. Their customer service was amazing. They really went out of their way to rush my order for a special occasion, which I truly appreciated. Beautiful craftsmanship and even better than I expected. You can tell a lot of care goes into their work. Highly recommend!

5
Date of experience: Mar 19, 2026
Matt E
Great gift !

I ordered a gift for my girlfriend and it was exactly what I was hoping for. It arrived on time, beautifully packaged, and the piece itself looked even better in person. She loved it, which is all that matters!

5
Date of experience: Mar 18, 2026
Helen Owens
This is my third purchase form sarah…

This is my third purchase form sarah elise and every piece has been beautiful. At this point I just trust anything ı order from this stop. 😍

5
Date of experience: Mar 05, 2026
I purchased a bracelet from here that…

I purchased a bracelet from here that was too small, which was my fault. It eventually broke as it was too tight, not due to poor quality. I asked if they could repair and an extender and they responded quickly. Minimal charge for my request and the repair and extension was completed and returned to me in less than a week. I can’t say enough good things about their CS and quality. Thank u guys very much, will be purchasing from them again!

5
Date of experience: Mar 03, 2026
ESRA ÇİFTÇİ
Thank you soooo muchhhh! 😊

At first I had some concerns, but my product arrived right on time. It looks really high quality — I just hope I won’t be disappointed. Thank you soooo muchhhh! 😊

5
Date of experience: Mar 02, 2026
mike hart
Wasn’t delivered on time as promised

Wasn’t delivered on time as promised. Then I called customer support before it was even shipped and was promised it would be sent that Monday overnight and that didn’t happen. The necklace was delivered in a nice box and my girlfriend thought it was fake gold because of how it was packaged. Will never order from them again.

1
Date of experience: Feb 19, 2026
Betty MD
horrible quality and customer service!

horrible quality and customer service!i purchased a diamond baguette tennis bracelet and the diamonds fell out within weeks. they wanted me to cover shipping costs to repair it, which is outrageous as still under warranty. the bracelet was repaired and now the chain has broken.they are blaming me for wearing the item while i sleep. this was not specified under warranty.my jeweler evaluated the bracelet and states that it is poorly made.they do no stand behind their pieces which are not sturdy or durable.do not purchase anything from sarah elise!

1
Date of experience: Feb 18, 2026
Anton Sinelnikov
Damaging Skin Reaction and Zero Customer Support – Very Disappointing Experience

I am extremely disappointed with my experience. I purchased a 14K white gold ring as a Valentine’s gift for my wife, but shortly after wearing it, she developed a severe skin reaction — irritation, cracking, and even bleeding on both hands. This is completely unacceptable for a product that is advertised as solid gold.What makes the situation worse is the lack of customer support. I have sent two emails and also tried calling, but after an entire month, I have received no response at all.Very upsetting experience both in terms of product quality and customer service.

1
Date of experience: Feb 14, 2026
Michael Sanchez
engagement ring

I got an engagement ring from Sarah Elsie Jewelry and the whole process was way easier than I expected. We did everything over email, and they were super responsive and helpful the entire time. I had a lot of questions, but they made it feel simple and stress-free. Couldn’t be happier with how it all turned out.

5
Date of experience: Feb 11, 2026

Is this your business?

Claim your business profile now and gain access to all features and respond to customer reviews.

Business Details

We use cookies to personalize your experience. By continuing to visit this website you agree to our use of cookies

More